Essay 9 of 13 · Movement III: Reading the Machines

The Invisible Auction

In 2022 Meta’s share price was down 35%, and I put the number at the top of an article for business owners with a question under it: do you know what they’re trying to do? Yep, make more money. Marketers have a dichotomous relationship with digital advertising channels like Linkedin or Google. We want to use their platform as cheaply as possible. They want us to use their platform as expensively as possible. I’d been buying traffic from those machines for ten years by then, and I still recommended them, with one caution, which I still mean: we never know what Facebook or Google will decide to do tomorrow.

With the invention of the platforms there were very real opportunities, and over the long term I suppose they were arbitrage opportunities, but in the moment they felt like permanent structural shifts.

The rest of this essay is in Marketing Curious.

Further exploration

The people, clips and books behind this essay. Clips and posts load from the site they live on, and only after you press play.

  1. Post · LinkedIn

    Marketers who learned the job through the lens of their marketing tech

    Liam Moroney

    From the essay “How, how, how, never why or when or how much.”

  2. Essay

    TikTok, attention share, and networks turning from growth to revenue

    Scott Galloway (No Mercy / No Malice)

    From the essay “they felt like permanent structural shifts”

  3. Report · 2018

    Effectiveness in Context: A Manual for Brand Building

    Les Binet and Peter Field (IPA)

    From the essay “The 95-5 rule”

  4. Clip · Instagram

    Which community were you part of to be fed this video?

    Oliver Oxford

    From the essay “I run the campaigns and I’m in the buckets.”

  5. Ad · Instagram

    A retargeting ad that tells you it saw you on the landing page

    Jon Loomer

    From the essay “if you’ve gone on someone’s website and they’ve got a tracking cookie, we could retarget you”

  6. Clip · Instagram

    Four things from Careless People, Sarah Wynn-Williams’ book about working at Facebook

    Alex Falcone

    From the essay “do you know what they’re trying to do?”

  7. Clip · Instagram

    Spotify and the revenue in your listening data

    Adam Conover with Liz Pelly

    From the essay “that’s the role of the ad platform to aggregate that information”

  8. Clip · Instagram

    Meta’s Ray-Ban launch and influence moving into closed networks

    Eugene Healey

    From the essay “hidden and obscured between more layers”

  9. Article

    The T-shaped marketer: deep in one channel, broad across the rest

    DigitalMarketer

    From the essay “they lack a more formal marketing education”